Research · Indoor environmental quality

Indoor Air Quality in Low-Income Housing

An indoor-air-quality field study investigating household monitoring and environmental episodes using Awair Element, IQAir AirVisual Pro, time-series analysis, PCA and k-means clustering.

The analysis examined 1,404 intentionally overlapping windows across five households.
Diagram in text
Coordinate access
Work with community and program partners.
Install monitors
11 installations yielded five usable records.
Detect changes
Identify changes and retain six-hour windows.
Group profiles
Apply PCA and k-means to standardized features.
Inspect the traces
Compare profiles with measured sensor curves.

Interactive tools

Approach and contribution

See the results

30-second case brief

From household installations to interpretable environmental records.

Problem
How can residential IAQ monitoring work within a whole-home improvement program, and what can its environmental records reveal?
My contribution
Led monitor preparation, household installations, data extraction, analytical development and the first-author field-study paper.
Outcome
The published field study documents 54 targeted homes, 11 installations and five usable datasets. A reproducible exploratory analysis retains 1,404 intentionally overlapping six-hour windows and describes three environmental-profile groups under the primary analysis. Household composition and sensitivity checks define the limits of that grouping.

ApproachCommunity-engaged mixed methods · multisensor monitoring · coverage-gated time series · regression-slope detection · standardized features · PCA and k-means

Project description and responsibility

Context
Drexel University with Philadelphia Energy Authority (PEA), Energy Coordinating Agency (ECA) and Esperanza
My role
Project lead for the research workflow; field installations, data preparation, modeling, interpretation and first-author writing
Collaboration
PEA program access, ECA household coordination and retrieval, Esperanza community relationships; publication with S. Hoque
Instrumentation
Awair Element and IQAir AirVisual Pro; four-channel AirVisual exports for the event analysis
Methods
Ten-minute medians; six-observation regression; six-hour windows; 12 standardized features; PCA; k-means
Outputs
2024 RBDCC field-study paper and presentation; October 2026 analytical manuscript, reproducible five-household analysis and pseudonymous result figures

Interactive tool · fieldwork planner

Stress-test an occupied-housing IAQ deployment.

Adjust four field conditions. The planner identifies the weakest link and the next preparation priority before monitoring begins.

Planning signal65/ 100

Priority before deployment

Plan for offline data continuity.

Connectivity is the current bottleneck. Add local buffering, visible device-status checks, and a recovery plan before relying on remote transfer.

54households in the recruitment frame
11monitor installations
5complete usable datasets

The 54 → 11 → 5 sequence reports the documented study. The adjustable planning signal is illustrative and does not estimate recruitment or completion probability.

Beginning with the community project

Connecting weatherization to the indoor environment

The study began within Philadelphia’s Built to Last program, led by the Philadelphia Energy Authority. The program coordinates home repairs, energy conservation and healthy-home services for low-wealth homeowners. Energy Coordinating Agency’s weatherization work connects home evaluation and energy education with measures such as air sealing, insulation and ventilation. This created a practical setting for asking how the indoor environment could be monitored alongside improvements to a home.

The research question was operational as well as environmental: which monitors could be installed, how could data be retrieved, and how could residents’ experiences be collected alongside the measurements? I led the research workflow from monitor preparation and household visits through data extraction, analysis and writing. PEA connected the study to its applicant pathway, ECA supported contact, visit coordination and retrieval, and Esperanza contributed established community relationships. The fieldwork paper was published with S. Hoque.

PEA: Built to Last program context ECA: weatherization services
The documented monitoring pathway connects program access to a recoverable dataset. Installation involved a Drexel researcher and an ECA agent; retrieval was planned at least two weeks after weatherization.

Published field study, printed pp. 476–477

Open full-size figure

Choosing monitors that could support the fieldwork

A common environmental core, with complementary measurements

Awair Element and the field-era IQAir AirVisual Pro both provided PM2.5, carbon dioxide, temperature and relative humidity. These shared variables made it possible to examine particle changes together with the surrounding thermal and CO₂ conditions. Awair also provided a TVOC channel, adding another view of the indoor environment. The event analysis uses the four shared AirVisual export channels, with PM2.5 as the trigger variable.

The selection also had to work in occupied homes. A readable display supported communication with residents, while setup, power, Wi-Fi access, monitor placement, data retrieval and maintenance determined whether a device could produce a usable record. Preparation and side-by-side comparison therefore came before deployment. The photograph shows that preparation arrangement, while the channel table identifies the measurements carried into analysis.

Awair Element channel documentation Field-era AirVisual Pro user guide
Manufacturer-documented air-quality channels
Channel / unitAwair ElementField-era AirVisual Pro
PM2.5 · µg/m³MeasuredMeasured
CO₂ · ppmMeasuredMeasured
Temperature · °CMeasuredMeasured
Relative humidity · % RHMeasuredMeasured
TVOC · ppbAdditional channelNot listed in the 2021 guide

Awair support (2024) and AirVisual Pro user guide (2021)

Monitor preparation and comparison arrangement before the household deployment. The photograph records the setup used to prepare the devices.

Project conference presentation

Open full-size figure

Making the monitoring plan work inside homes

Installation, participant communication and retrieval

ECA contacted eligible households about their interest in monitoring and their access to Wi-Fi, then coordinated installation appointments. I installed and prepared monitors within this partner-supported process, checking power, connectivity and a practical location with the household. Placement mattered because a monitor’s record depends on airflow, proximity to sources and obstructions, as well as on the device itself.

The environmental measurements were paired with participant communication through in-person surveys, phone calls and online surveys, including respiratory-health and wellbeing questions. Follow-up, retrieval and extraction completed the monitoring loop. The published field record documents 54 targeted households, 11 installations and five usable datasets. These are separate stages of the field process, rather than interchangeable sample sizes.

The published deployment progression. Counts refer to households, not sensor readings or detected events.

Published field study, printed p. 476

Open full-size figure

Why technical and social decisions had to be made together

The field experience organized itself into four connected domains. Participants needed clear explanations of the study, privacy and what monitoring involved. Collaborators provided access and trust, but their responsibilities and schedules had to remain coordinated. Logistics connected appointments, electrical outlets, monitor locations, survey timing and retrieval. Technical continuity depended on Wi-Fi, device maintenance and successful extraction.

Connectivity was especially consequential: the published study reports that more than 27 of the 54 potential homes lacked stable usable Wi-Fi. That experience linked the fieldwork directly to the next analytical stage. A long apparent monitoring period could contain substantial gaps, so the analysis had to establish what was actually observed before interpreting changes in indoor conditions.

The source-grounded field framework. Each domain affects whether monitoring reaches a usable record and how that record can be interpreted.

Published field study, printed pp. 479–482

Open full-size figure

Turning irregular exports into comparable records

Preserving measured coverage before creating a common time grid

The analytical extension reconciles 49 AirVisual exports from five household folders. Exact duplicate records were removed and conflicting timestamps excluded. The retained export spans run from September 2022 to June 2023 for H01 and H03 and from March to June 2023 for H02, H04 and H05. These spans describe supplied records; deployment and device-movement logs were not sufficient to confirm that every retained timestamp represented an occupied-home deployment. The four channels retain their named physical units, with household pseudonyms H01 to H05.

A ten-minute grid provides a common resolution for comparison. Each observed bin uses the median of its available readings. Linear interpolation is restricted to gaps of at most two missing bins and requires observations on both sides. Longer outages remain missing. A six-hour event window is retained only when all four channels are available and at least 80% of its bins are measured. The coverage figure keeps those measured values separate from the short filled gaps.

Measured coverage ranges from 2.10% in H02 to 95.09% in H01. H01 has a median 60 source readings per nonempty ten-minute bin, compared with two in each other home. The primary PM2.5 screen excludes values above 1,000 µg/m³ as an analysis convention. Sensitivities retaining or capping those readings change the fitted partition, so screening and concentration accuracy must be considered separately. Missing records are not assumed to be random.

Observed bins in each available export span
HouseholdMeasured 10-minute binsMeasured share
H0140,91995.09%
H023412.10%
H0334,90782.10%
H042,81517.32%
H0512,33375.96%

Same coverage-gated analytical run

Measured, short-gap-filled and unavailable ten-minute bins within each household export span, and retained six-hour contextual windows. Span includes outages and is not verified occupancy or deployment duration. Household labels are pseudonyms.

Research manuscript, October 2026; unpublished

Open full-size figure

Finding concentration changes, then keeping their context

A regression slope identifies sustained changes in PM2.5

The detector fits a line to six consecutive ten-minute PM2.5 values, spanning 50 minutes between labels. A trigger requires a positive slope greater than 4 µg/m³ per ten-minute index step, equivalent to 0.4 µg/m³/min, and a local range of at least 20 µg/m³. At least two of the trigger and next six values must exceed the six-point local minimum by more than 20 µg/m³. Those two values need not be consecutive or measured.

After a qualifying trigger, repeat triggers are suppressed until two consecutive measured bins return to within 20 µg/m³ of the local baseline after an elevation, a PM2.5 outage occurs, or a 72-hour cap is reached. The coverage gate then determines whether a complete four-channel context is retained. Look-ahead, interpolation and the post-trigger context make this a retrospective analysis; real-time detection performance has not been established.

Actual event example: shaded points are the six observations used for the regression; the dashed line marks the first retained trigger. Concentration and time have separate, explicit units.

Five-household analytical rerun

Open full-size figure

The six-hour window carries the other variables into interpretation

Each retained context begins one hour before the trigger and contains 36 ten-minute bins over the half-open interval [-1, 5) hours. Nearby windows intentionally share context. In this library, 811 of 1,399 adjacent within-household pairs overlap, and 50,544 window-bin slots use 35,935 unique ten-minute bins. These are dependence diagnostics, not independent sample sizes or counts of household activities.

Returning to the measured curves makes the event concrete. In this example, the particle excursion can be followed beside its CO₂, temperature and relative-humidity context. The channels evolve on their own scales, and their changes are not interchangeable. Plotting them separately preserves those relationships and gives the feature-based analysis a traceable environmental reference.

Dots identify measured bins; lines show the ten-minute analysis series, including any bounded short-gap interpolation. Time is relative to the window start. PM2.5 is µg/m³, CO₂ ppm, temperature °C and relative humidity %.

Actual retained window from the analytical rerun

Open full-size figure

Grouping environmental profiles without losing the measurements

Twelve physical features become a smaller comparison space

Each window contributes the mean, sample standard deviation and range of PM2.5, CO₂, temperature and relative humidity. The 12 features are standardized before PCA. This handles unit scales but does not remove correlated-feature redundancy or give each household equal influence. Household labels and timestamps remain metadata, outside the fitted features.

Six components retain 95.793% of standardized feature variance. K-means candidates from two through ten groups are compared using the archived minimum-size and repeat-seed criteria, then the lowest eligible Davies–Bouldin index. This rule selects three groups. The four-group fit has a lower Davies–Bouldin index but its smallest group has 14 windows, below the required 14.04, meaning at least 15 integer windows. The two-group fit has a higher silhouette score. Three groups is therefore a conditional descriptive choice.

StandardScaler and PCA are fitted to the full exploratory window library. Candidate groups use the saved size and random-seed gates. The four-group solution has a lower Davies–Bouldin index but its smallest group has 14 windows, below the required 14.04 (at least 15 integer windows). Selection of three groups is conditional on this rule.

Research manuscript, October 2026; unpublished

Open full-size figure

Inspect the groups in feature space and in their measured time series

The first two principal components display 53.941% of standardized feature variance and provide a view of the grouped windows. The grouping itself uses all six retained components, so the two-dimensional scatter is a projection of the full comparison. Each point is one six-hour window, not a household or a single sensor observation.

For interpretation, the closest actual window to each group’s centroid in PCA space is returned to its four measured channels. These representative windows show different particle excursions, CO₂ levels and thermal trajectories. They are observed examples from the records, rather than synthetic centroid curves. Common axis ranges within each channel make the profiles directly comparable.

The grouping uses all six retained principal components. The plot displays PC1 and PC2 only, jointly representing 53.941% of standardized feature variance.

Five-household analytical rerun

Open full-size figure

Actual windows nearest each fitted group centroid in retained PCA space. Axes are shared within channels, with separate physical units. Trigger is at zero; the 36 left-labelled ten-minute bins cover [−1, 5) hours. These are contextual measured/short-gap-filled traces, not reconstructed time series or identified household activities.

Research manuscript, October 2026; unpublished

Open full-size figure

Results: usable records, detected episodes and recurring profiles

The event library now spans all five household exports

The coverage-gated workflow retains 1,404 contextual windows: H01 1,116; H02 6; H03 133; H04 24; and H05 125. H01 contributes 79.49% of the library. These counts reflect available spans, measured coverage and detected PM2.5 changes. They do not estimate household activity frequency or prevalence.

The primary three-group fit has Davies–Bouldin index 1.3055, silhouette 0.3295 and median repeat-seed adjusted Rand index 1.000. These measure internal structure and repeat-run consistency on the same records. They do not establish stable classes or accurate prediction in new households.

From consolidated candidates to retained context
HouseholdCandidatesRetained windows
H011,1291,116
H0286
H03187133
H042724
H05153125

Five-household result registry

Counts of retained windows, not activity frequencies or prevalence estimates. Each household is assessed from its own available export span with the same coverage gate.

Analytical rerun · 14 October 2026

Open full-size figure

Household composition changes the interpretation

Group 2 contains 239 H01 windows out of 261, or 91.57%. Group 3 contains 79 H05 windows out of 114, or 69.30%. All five homes contribute to groups 1 and 3, and profiles also vary within homes. The groups describe both environmental variation and strongly unequal household representation.

At fixed three groups, a disjoint-window subset has adjusted Rand index 0.990 against the primary labels on shared windows. Equal-household weighting reduces agreement to 0.344, robust scaling to 0.342 and logarithmic PM2.5/CO₂ features to 0.295. Each sensitivity refits preprocessing, PCA and k-means. Removing overlap alone therefore does not account for the primary partition, while household weighting and representation materially affect it. Equal weighting is a different descriptive target, not an automatic correction for sparse or missing records.

Adjusted Rand index (ARI) measures partition agreement on identical shared windows. The sensitivity chart holds the number of groups at three; the manuscript separately reports the group counts selected again within each sensitivity.

Profile composition under the reproduced window-weighted three-group solution. H01 contributes 239/261 windows in group 2 and H05 contributes 79/114 in group 3. Panel B uses different denominators and shows that profiles also vary within homes.

Research manuscript, October 2026; unpublished

Open full-size figure

Partition agreement with the primary fit while holding k = 3. Every sensitivity refits scaling, PCA and k-means. Comparisons use exact shared household/trigger keys. Equal weighting and centering change the descriptive target; they are stress tests, not automatically better estimates. Selected k varies separately in Table 3 of the manuscript.

Research manuscript, October 2026; unpublished

Open full-size figure

Stability within these records

One hundred seven-day block resamples per weighting scheme refit the full fixed-three-group pipeline. Median agreement is 0.930 for the primary weighting, with empirical 2.5th–97.5th percentiles 0.835–0.973. Equal-household weighting gives median 0.921 with a wider 0.279–0.977 range against its own original weighted fit. These are conditional perturbation ranges, not confidence intervals or validation in new homes.

In a random 80/20 window-split diagnostic, an average 72.89% of test windows share source bins with training windows. A chronological split with a 72-hour purge on each side and train-only preprocessing reduces direct overlap leakage, but remains an internal diagnostic because the detector was developed using these same source homes. Five households remain the higher-level sampling units.

One hundred resamples per weighting scheme, resampling seven-day bins separately within households, including empty bins. Each resample refits scaling, PCA and fixed-k = 3 k-means and predicts the fixed library. Lines show empirical 2.5th–97.5th percentiles; ticks show medians. These are conditional perturbation ranges, not confidence intervals or validation in new homes. Some resamples contain only four homes.

Research manuscript, October 2026; unpublished

Open full-size figure

An archived signal-reference check

The preserved protocol describes sensor-trace annotations made without viewing detector outputs. Thirteen earlier blocks supported method development and checking; four subsequently selected day-long blocks provide the archived fresh comparison. Re-running the scoring verifies the numerical matches but cannot independently establish the annotation process. These are concentration-pattern references, not participant-confirmed activity labels.

The four blocks contain five rising references, four in H01 and one in H05. All five match retained triggers; H03 and H04 each contribute a negative block with no retained candidate. Three additional downward changes are outside the positive-rise target. The counts remain the same with 0, 10 or 20 minutes of matching tolerance. This selected five-positive check is too small and concentrated to support a population detection-rate claim.

Archived signal-reference counts (positive-rise target)
MeasureObserved count
Day-long review blocks4
Rising signal references5
One-to-one matched rises5
Unmatched retained candidates0
Negative blocks with zero candidates2
All-direction references8
Unmatched downward changes3

One-to-one matches unchanged at 0, 10 and 20 minutes of timing tolerance

The archived four-block check contains five rising signal references. Shading marks their manually marked intervals; dashed lines mark retained triggers. Two negative blocks returned zero candidates. All times are relative and household labels are pseudonyms.

Archived signal-reference annotations; scoring reproduced 14 October 2026

Open full-size figure

The grouped result stays tied to physical conditions

The group summaries quantify what the profiles represent. The largest group (Group 1) contains 1,029 windows across 5 homes. Group 3 has the highest median window-average CO₂ concentration (639 ppm), while Group 2 has the largest median PM2.5 range (484.9 µg/m³). The representative curves show how those feature differences appear over time.

The comparison combines PM2.5-triggered episodes with their wider environmental context. The measured examples show that similar particle changes can occur with different CO₂ and thermal conditions. Keeping the original curves, units and feature summaries together makes that result useful for reviewing the environmental record and selecting periods for closer investigation.

Physical summaries of the retained groups
GroupWindowsMedian PM2.5 mean (µg/m³)Median PM2.5 range (µg/m³)Median CO₂ mean (ppm)
11,02931.80135.55473.64
2261111.82484.90522.82
311426.42115.32639.07

Each entry is the median of the corresponding window-level feature

The final output connects field design to interpretable data

The published field study translated the installations and participant interactions into a four-domain framework and practical recommendations. The analysis extends that work from securing usable records to inspecting concentration-change episodes, reducing their multivariate features with PCA and returning grouped results to actual measurements.

The contribution is a reproducible exploratory description of PM2.5-triggered contexts in the available five-home records. Original exports, analysis choices, source-linked figures and sensitivity results are documented in the full manuscript and private reproducibility package. Generalization requires additional households, deployment and calibration records, and independent reference observations. The present data do not establish household activity prevalence, health effects or before/after retrofit benefits.

Read the full analytical manuscript (PDF)
Field-study recommendations linked to the monitoring workflow
RecommendationPractical purpose
Accessible IAQ educationExplain the measurements and the monitoring process
Privacy and informed-consent protocolsEstablish transparent expectations with households
Durable community partnershipsSupport access, trust and follow-up
Flexible scheduling and communicationCoordinate installations, surveys and retrieval
Connectivity and sensing alternativesPlan for power, data continuity and pollutant coverage
Equipment and research fundingSupport preparation, maintenance and field capacity
An integrated field planCoordinate technical requirements with participant and partner needs

Published field study, printed pp. 482–484

Complete analytical record

Overlapping indoor air quality windows in five low income households

Research manuscript, October 2026; unpublished.

The complete project record

Full book

Read the complete report, thesis, or presentation here. Use the page controls to explore the original figures and methods.

Download PDF Open full PDF

Published RBDCC paper · R. Tajik and S. Hoque · printed pp. 471–487

Challenges in Mixed Methods Research: IAQ in Low-Income Households

The original document, page by page.

The reader loads when you open the book.

Contact

Do you have a question or want to chat?

Analytics preferences

Optional Google Analytics uses cookies to measure page visits and engagement. You can browse the entire portfolio with analytics off.

Analytics is off in this browser.

Privacy details. Change your choice here at any time. Your preference is remembered for up to 180 days.