Approach and contribution
30-second case brief
Building systems evaluated as one operating sequence.
- Problem
- Coordinate the thermal, ventilation, daylight, and control behavior of an integrated low-energy housing precedent.
- My contribution
- Project lead and major contributor across modeling, analysis and controls, with independent development of the BIPV analysis.
- Outcome
- Reported annual sensible heating and cooling loads fall from 34.46 to 4.20 kWh/m². The final stage places 83.53% of 5,688 climate-eligible modeled Zone 2 hours within the Category II temperature band and reports 6,514.32 kWh/year of PV generation.
- Explore the evidence
ApproachTRNSYS · TRNBUILD · adaptive comfort feedback · staged energy comparison · running-mean temperature-band reassessment.
Study basis
The Home for Life study brought the building envelope, indoor conditions and environmental systems into one TRNSYS simulation workflow. The objective was to understand how these systems could work together to improve thermal comfort and reduce heating and cooling loads throughout the year.
I led the collaborative project and contributed across modeling, analysis, control development and presentation. I independently developed the BIPV analysis, connecting roof-integrated photovoltaic generation with the building's thermal and electrical assessment.
The final study reported annual sensible heating and cooling loads of 4.20 kWh/m² and photovoltaic generation of 6,514.32 kWh per year. The running-mean reassessment places 83.53% of climate-eligible modeled Zone 2 hours within the EN 15251:2007 Category II temperature band.
- Context
- Politecnico di Milano, 2020
- Role
- Project lead and major contributor
- Platform
- TRNSYS, TRNBUILD and TRNEdit
- Study focus
- Energy, adaptive comfort and daylight

Model developmentRepresenting the building as connected thermal zones
The analysis began with the existing Home for Life house and its documented geometry, construction and operating schedules. The team created a three-dimensional model using the TRNSYS3D extension for SketchUp, then imported its building description into TRNSYS. Each surface was assigned to a thermal zone and identified as external, ground-coupled or adjacent to another zone.
The resulting model contained two ground-floor zones and one upper-floor zone. Zone 2 was the double-height living space, so its operative temperature became the main feedback variable for the comfort-control study. This connected the simulations to a specific place in the building. Conditions in the shared living space were evaluated alongside the annual building-wide load results.

Envelope and climateSeparating insulation performance from thermal storage
Three envelope constructions were compared: the original construction, a lightweight alternative and a massive alternative. Their thermal transmittance values were kept close enough to examine the effects of construction beyond insulation alone. The comparison therefore included thermal mass, time shift and periodic thermal transmittance, alongside the conventional U-value.
For the external wall, the massive option increased the reported mass per area to 312.6 kg/m², compared with 87.93 kg/m² for the original wall and 62.3 kg/m² for the lightweight option. Its wall time shift was 16.94 hours, compared with 13.95 and 9.75 hours. These outputs showed how the envelope could store heat and change the timing of indoor temperature changes, which made it relevant to the later ventilation and shading decisions.
Reading the conditions the building would need to respond to
The climate analysis compared Tirstrup, Bergamo and Trapani before evaluating the building systems. The annual outdoor-temperature means in the weather inputs were 7.63°C, 13.94°C and 18.05°C respectively. The hourly temperature maps also showed when those conditions occurred, which mattered for a controller that would respond to seasonal and daily changes.
Within each climate, the team compared combinations of the three envelope options, three ventilation rates and three shading fractions. Bergamo became the setting for the detailed coupled-system development presented here, using the massive envelope as its construction basis. The climate record supplied the outdoor conditions for the adaptive-comfort calculation, ground-temperature model and air-source comparisons.

Adaptive thermal comfortTurning indoor comfort into a control input
Establishing the development baseline
The system-development sequence used the massive-envelope Bergamo model with 0.6 air changes per hour and a 50% shading setting. The running-mean reassessment places 1,479 of 5,688 climate-eligible modeled hours (26.00%) within the EN 15251:2007 Category II temperature band. The temperature record explains why coordinated control was the next step: indoor conditions changed with the seasons and with the interaction between solar gains, ventilation and the envelope.
Operative temperature was used to represent the indoor condition. It accounts for both air temperature and the surrounding radiant environment, so it connects the comfort assessment to changes in the building surfaces as well as to the air supplied by ventilation. This made it a useful shared variable for evaluating the different systems.
Assessing the hourly outputs against a running-mean benchmark
The EN 15251:2007 adaptive temperature-band benchmark relates indoor operative temperature to recent outdoor conditions. For each simulation day, the reassessment uses Trm[d] = 0.8 × Trm[d−1] + 0.2 × Tdaily[d−1]. The previous running mean carries 80% of the weight and the previous day's outdoor mean carries 20%. This value remains constant during the day, so the assessment follows the preceding weather history rather than the outdoor temperature at that hour.
Category II uses an upper limit of 0.33 × Trm + 21.8°C and a lower limit of 0.33 × max(Trm, 15) + 15.8°C. The lower boundary stays at 20.75°C between running means of 10 and 15°C. Both band endpoints are included. Category I provides a narrower comparison and Category III a wider one. The same rules and outdoor-temperature sequence are applied to all five stages.
The running mean is within the 10–30°C assessment domain for 5,688 hours, covering 64.93% of the 8,760-hour simulation. The remaining 3,072 hours fall below that domain and are left unassessed. Every stage percentage therefore uses the same 5,688-hour denominator. To initialize the running mean, the calculation assumes periodic repetition of the supplied 365-day weather sequence.
The scatter plots pair each original Zone 2 hourly temperature with its reassessed running mean. The final BIPV-stage outputs cluster much more closely around the bands than the baseline, connecting the numerical comparison to the actual simulated temperature response.
Defining the original controller's temperature range
The adaptive-comfort workflow evaluated indoor operative temperature against a range linked to outdoor thermal conditions. In the TRNSYS implementation, a floating-mean outdoor-temperature component supplied the reference temperature. The controller calculated its upper and lower operative-temperature limits from that input, with a lower bound of 20°C and an upper bound of 31°C.
The nominal equations were 0.33 × Trm + 16 for the lower limit and 0.33 × Trm + 21.5 for the upper limit, subject to those bounds. The figure makes this relationship visible: the control range shifts as outdoor conditions change. These are the historical implemented control rules. They remain distinct from the continuous EN temperature-band limits used in the retrospective running-mean reassessment above.
Using the previous hour to choose the next action
The comfort equation produced a feedback signal that distinguished below-range, comfortable and above-range conditions. These principal states were coded as −1, 1 and 2. The previous hour's result was then used as an input to the following control decision, together with the relevant air and surface temperatures.
This feedback connected the comfort analysis to system operation. A ventilation decision could change the supply-air temperature and indoor conditions; the resulting comfort signal could then inform the next ventilation or shading step. The algorithm was developed as explicit equations and decision rules within the simulation, making the relationship between the inputs and the system response inspectable.
Floating-mean temperature defines the adaptive limits.
Compare the indoor condition with the control range.
The previous timestep informs the following decision.
Compare the available supply-air routes.
Choose a fraction and apply surface-temperature rules.
Ground-coupled ventilationDeveloping the air path before developing its controls
Comparing pipe depth and length
The ground-pipe study investigated how incoming air could be tempered before entering the building. The model used the more stable temperature below ground to exchange heat with the ventilation air. Pipe depth, length, number and diameter were then varied to compare their effect on outlet temperature over the year.
The depth comparison tested 1, 2 and 4 metres. The 4-metre option produced a smaller seasonal temperature swing, with warmer outlet air during winter and cooler outlet air during summer. At that depth, the length study compared 10, 20 and 30 metres. The 30-metre option further moderated the outlet-temperature curve, and these comparisons guided the ground-pipe configuration used in the design sequence.


Distributing the airflow across parallel pipes
The next comparison varied the number of parallel pipes while adjusting pipe diameter around the airflow and velocity assumptions. The investigated arrangements used one 0.25-metre pipe, three 0.15-metre pipes and five 0.10-metre pipes. The five-pipe arrangement produced the most moderated outlet temperatures in this comparison.
This stage converted the ground-coupling strategy into an air-supply option with a defined thermal response. It became one of the inputs to the ventilation controller, which compared ground-pipe air, direct outdoor air and heat recovery to select a route around the room's thermal condition.

Ventilation controlSelecting air sources around the room's thermal condition
The ventilation controller coordinated three routes: natural ventilation, ground-pipe air and ground-pipe air combined with air-to-air heat exchange. It compared outdoor, ground-pipe, exhaust and zone temperatures alongside the comfort feedback. The purpose was to select an air path that could support the room's current heating or cooling need.
The operating sequence was refined with a summer schedule that restricted natural ventilation during the peak ambient-temperature period, from 10:00 to 16:00. This connected the hourly route choice to the daily pattern of available cooling. The June 13 results show when the different routes operated and how the Zone 2 operative temperature developed alongside outdoor and ground-pipe temperatures.
Under the common running-mean benchmark, the ventilation-stage outputs contain 3,108 hours within Category II, or 54.64% of the 5,688 climate-eligible modeled hours. This stage provides the next comparison for the shading controller, which addresses the solar gains entering through the building's transparent surfaces.

Adaptive shading algorithmDeveloping the controller through three simulation stages
Stage 1: relating the shading fraction to comfort feedback
The initial shading workflow compared the comfort response of candidate shading fractions using saved simulation profiles. Those comparisons were translated into control equations, then combined with the hourly comfort feedback and operating schedule. Where candidate settings gave equal comfort performance, the selection logic favored less shading to retain more daylight.
The hourly record makes the decision sequence tangible. A shaded fraction of zero represents an open condition; larger fractions reduce the transparent area exposed to solar gains. The accompanying comfort signal shows the thermal context in which these changes occurred. Reading the two traces together connects the control rule to its simulated operation.
Stage 2: adding the envelope's thermal state
The second development stage added an external surface-temperature indicator to the comfort feedback. This gave the controller information about the envelope's solar heating as well as the room's operative temperature. The surface-temperature rule helped maintain shading when the envelope remained hot, even when the most recent indoor condition had returned to the comfort range.
The documented refinement used a 50°C surface-temperature threshold to call for the maximum shading ratio. This connected the control action to heat accumulating in the envelope and the likelihood of renewed indoor warming. The plotted traces show the surface-temperature indicator, selected shading fraction and comfort feedback over the same period, so the reader can inspect how those variables developed together.
Stage 3: controlling vertical and roof windows separately
The final development stage separated the roof-window controls from the vertical-window controls. Each could now respond to its own surface-temperature conditions while remaining connected to the comfort feedback. The vertical-window strategy retained the previous stage's thermal-state refinement, while the roof strategy introduced progressively stronger shading as roof surface temperature increased.
The documented roof-control sequence used thresholds of 35, 40, 45 and 50°C, associated with minimum shading fractions of 30%, 50%, 80% and full coverage. Separating the two window groups gave the system a more specific response to where solar heating occurred. The final shading-stage outputs contain 3,977 hours within Category II, or 69.92% of the 5,688 climate-eligible modeled hours in the running-mean benchmark.
Solar thermal and BIPVConnecting useful heat and electricity to the building model
Sizing the solar thermal system around its useful contribution
The solar thermal model connected the collector, hot-water storage and ventilation heating path. TRNEdit parametric runs varied collector area and compared the resulting solar fraction. The curve showed the relationship between additional collector area and its contribution to the system, allowing the roof allocation to be evaluated alongside space for photovoltaic generation.
The design sequence selected a 10 m² solar thermal collector. Its useful heat supported the domestic-hot-water system and could raise the ventilation supply-air temperature when the control conditions called for heating. This linked the collector-sizing decision to the temperature and comfort feedback already used by the ventilation strategy.
Modeling the BIPV assembly as part of the air path
I independently developed the BIPV analysis as the next solar layer in the study. The TRNSYS model represented the photovoltaic assembly's electrical generation and its thermal interaction with the air path. This allowed the roof-integrated system to be assessed alongside the ventilation and heating strategy, rather than as an isolated annual electricity calculation.
The unglazed BIPV model used Type 568 to represent heat transfer through the assembly and photovoltaic electricity production. Its useful heat could temper the ventilation air, and the annual results compared the resulting supply temperature with indoor operative temperature. This kept the thermal contribution of the roof system connected to the conditions being controlled in the living space.
Evaluating the photovoltaic generation profile
The reported photovoltaic output was 6,514.32 kWh per year, with monthly generation increasing toward summer and peaking in July. The roof arrangement connected photovoltaic placement with the solar thermal collector. Keeping the generation profile visible alongside the building-load assessment made the seasonal relationship between energy supply and demand part of the final design discussion.
Daylight and design decisionsChecking the lighting conditions created by the thermal strategy
Evaluating daylight across the occupied spaces
Daylight was evaluated alongside thermal performance because the shading fraction also changes the light available inside the house. The spatial analysis mapped daylight conditions across the floors, allowing the lighting assessment to be read against the building layout and the locations of rooms and openings.
The reported spatial daylight autonomy values were 64% and 100% for the two floor views, with corresponding annual sunlight exposure values of 38% and 36%. These outputs describe the spatial distribution of light under the documented daylight-analysis configuration. They complement the more detailed point analysis used to examine the automated shading in the living space.

Connecting the automated shading to the living-room experience
The automated-shading analysis placed a daylight evaluation point in Zone 2, at a height of 1 metre. Its hourly illuminance record showed 3,327 analyzed hours above 300 lux and 1,153 above 1,000 lux within the reported 4,745-hour evaluation. This brought the thermal-control strategy back to the light conditions at a specific position in the shared living space.
The resulting design proposal paired the automatic thermal shading with an occupant-operated curtain for periods of high illuminance. This gave the occupant a local way to adjust the visual environment alongside the building's automatic response to thermal conditions. The lighting strategy can therefore be read alongside the final energy and thermal-comfort outcomes below.


Integrated simulation resultsResults: the step-by-step energy and temperature response
The final comparison brings the development stages together, showing the reported annual heating and cooling loads, the corrected running-mean temperature-band assessment and solar electricity production.
Reducing heating and cooling loads at each stage
The starting model had a combined annual sensible heating and cooling load of 34.46 kWh/m². Incorporating the heat exchanger reduced that load to 27.48 kWh/m², a 20.3% reduction from the starting model. The ground-pipe ventilation stage brought it to 23.48 kWh/m², a further 14.6% reduction from the heat-exchanger stage.
Adaptive shading then reduced the combined load to 16.97 kWh/m², 27.7% below the preceding ventilation stage. Adding the solar thermal system brought it to 6.27 kWh/m², a further 63.1% reduction. The final BIPV-stage model reached 4.20 kWh/m², 33.0% below the solar-thermal stage. Each percentage describes the change from the immediately preceding model in the reported development sequence.
Together, these stages reduced the combined simulated sensible load by 87.8% relative to the starting model. Annual heating fell from 31.07 to 3.74 kWh/m², and cooling from 3.39 to 0.46 kWh/m². Keeping the heating and cooling components visible shows how the final result developed through the coordinated envelope, ventilation, shading and solar strategy.
Comparing all stages against the same adaptive benchmark
The corrected Zone 2 assessment compares every stage over the same 5,688 climate-eligible modeled hours. The share within the EN 15251:2007 Category II temperature band rises from 26.00% in the 50% shading baseline to 54.64% after ventilation, 69.92% after adaptive shading and 84.39% after solar thermal. The final BIPV stage places 83.53% within that band, 57.53 percentage points above the baseline.
The stage chart separates the nested bands into non-overlapping segments, then shows the hours colder or warmer than Category III. The table gives inclusive counts: Category I is included in II, and II is included in III. These columns should be compared across stages, not added together. The wider Category III band contains 92.95% of eligible final-stage hours, compared with 34.85% at baseline.
The distribution also explains the trade-offs within that progression. The baseline has 2,919 eligible hours above Category III and 787 below it. In the ventilation stage, above-band hours fall to 105 while below-band hours increase to 1,996. The shading and solar-thermal stages bring below-band hours to 737 and 252 respectively. Reading both sides of the band shows how the modeled sequence balances overheating and colder conditions rather than optimizing only one extreme.
The BIPV-stage Category II count is 49 hours lower than the solar-thermal stage, a decrease of 0.86 percentage points on the common denominator. The temperature-band outcome therefore does not improve at every step. These cumulative model stages show the combined system response rather than isolating the effect of each component.
The final design connects three complementary outputs: reported sensible heating and cooling loads of 4.20 kWh/m², 4,751 of 5,688 climate-eligible modeled Zone 2 hours within Category II, and annual photovoltaic generation of 6,514.32 kWh. The corrected temperature-band assessment adds a traceable running-mean comparison to the original model and control sequence. The energy and photovoltaic quantities remain the reported simulation results.
| Model stage | Category I | Category II | Category III |
|---|---|---|---|
| Baseline | 974 h 17.12% | 1,479 h 26.00% | 1,982 h 34.85% |
| Ventilation | 2,304 h 40.51% | 3,108 h 54.64% | 3,587 h 63.06% |
| Shading | 2,870 h 50.46% | 3,977 h 69.92% | 4,695 h 82.54% |
| Solar thermal | 3,780 h 66.46% | 4,800 h 84.39% | 5,288 h 92.97% |
| BIPV | 3,727 h 65.52% | 4,751 h 83.53% | 5,287 h 92.95% |
Read the unchanged original report below. The running-mean reassessment is documented separately in the methods and stage-results dataset.
The complete project record
Full book
Read the complete report, thesis, or presentation here. Use the page controls to explore the original figures and methods.
Home for Life - Energy Efficient Building
The original document, page by page.
The reader loads when you open the book.
