HOME FOR LIFE: RUNNING-MEAN TEMPERATURE-BAND ASSESSMENT Reassessment dated October 14, 2026 Purpose Compare saved Zone 2 operative temperatures across five cumulative model stages using an EN 15251:2007 adaptive temperature-band benchmark. This is retrospective postprocessing, not a TRNSYS rerun. Original controls, trajectories, energy and photovoltaic results, report and workbooks are unchanged. Source and time basis Each stage supplies 8,760 finite hourly Zone 2 operative temperatures. Baseline: the 50% shading system-development case (massive envelope, Bergamo, 0.6 ACH), from Hourly_50.txt, TOP_Zone-2, simulation times 1 through 8760. Other stages: DATA column K, rows 5 through 8764, of the preserved stage workbooks. Outdoor temperature is the matching DATA column H series, identical across stages. Hour endings 1-24 form simulation day 1. Time-zero initialization and the extra spreadsheet row are excluded. No civil year, time zone or daylight-saving schedule is inferred. Running mean Tdaily[d] is the mean of the 24 outdoor temperatures of day d. Trm[d] = 0.8 Trm[d-1] + 0.2 Tdaily[d-1]. Only preceding days are used. The result stays constant throughout day d. Initialization assumes periodic repetition of the supplied 365-day weather sequence. The periodic day-1 value is 1.9381783719334307 degrees Celsius. Domain and bands Assess only 10 <= Trm <= 30 degrees Celsius. This gives 5,688 eligible hours (237 days), or 64.93% of 8,760 hours. The other 3,072 hours have Trm below 10 degrees Celsius and are unassessed, not failures. Upper = 0.33 Trm + 18.8 + offset. Lower = 0.33 max(Trm, 15) + 18.8 - offset. Offsets: I = 2, II = 3, III = 4 degrees Celsius. Both band endpoints are included. No elevated-air-speed extension is used. Category counts are nested: I is included in II; II is included in III. Percentages use 5,688 hours. Category II results Baseline: 1,479 hours, 26.00%; ventilation: 3,108 hours, 54.64%; shading: 3,977 hours, 69.92%; solar thermal: 4,800 hours, 84.39%; BIPV: 4,751 hours, 83.53%. BIPV has 49 fewer Category II hours than solar thermal, a difference of -0.86 percentage points. Cumulative stages do not isolate component effects. Adaptive_results.csv provides all category counts and denominators, plus separately labeled fractions of all 8,760 hours. Annual fractions are not annual compliance rates. No occupant satisfaction percentage is inferred. Interpretation The comparison includes all climate-eligible modeled hours without occupancy weighting. The saved scenarios include automatic and tempered ventilation and solar-assisted heat. Stage-by-stage operating status, occupancy and adaptive occupant control are not fully established. These figures are a temperature- band benchmark, not standards compliance, annual occupied comfort or measured performance. The original capped/floored controller equations are distinct from the continuous bands used in this assessment. Validation The five operative-temperature series and identical weather vectors were checked. The raw baseline matches its converted workbook below 1.1e-13 degrees Celsius. Recurrence and independent periodic exponential summation agree within 3.6e-14 degrees Celsius. Independent scalar classification reproduces all category counts. Nested and disjoint partitions reconcile to the denominator. Using the first day's weather mean as an alternative initialization changes no eligible-hour count or Category II count. References Original Home for Life report (model/control and historical results), pp. 40, 44, 55-56 and 70-71, and the preserved hourly outputs and stage workbooks. EN 15251:2007, definition 3.11 and Annex A.2 (historical project convention). Standard preview: https://cdn.standards.iteh.ai/samples/24552/0f4e05d56b9a48ea912214b0055a8b3b/SIST-EN-15251-2007.pdf EnergyPlus 24.2 Engineering Reference, EN15251-2007 adaptive model: https://bigladdersoftware.com/epx/docs/24-2/engineering-reference/occupant-thermal-comfort.html