Approach and contribution
30-second case brief
The evidence gap is occupant engagement.
- Problem
- Understand how circadian-supportive lighting research connects biological response, light-exposure systems, and occupant engagement.
- Contribution
- Conceived the three-domain framework and led evidence curation, screening, synthesis, visualization, and manuscript development as first author.
- Result
- Mapped 728 qualified publications grouped into 646 study families. Qualifying occupant engagement appears in 89/646 families (13.8%), compared with 604/646 (93.5%) for light-exposure systems.
ApproachSystematic verification and screening · study-family mapping · three-domain classification.
Project scope and responsibility
- Context
- Systematic evidence map and conceptual framework · Submitted manuscript
- Role
- First author and project lead
- Evidence base
- 728 qualified publications with complete reports · 646 study families
- Scope
- Biological response · light-exposure systems · occupant engagement
- Publication
- Submitted manuscript · DOI not yet assigned
Result evidence
| Domain | Families | Share |
|---|---|---|
| Non-Visual Biological Responses | 646/646 | 100.0% |
| Light-Exposure Systems | 604/646 | 93.5% |
| Qualifying Occupant Engagement | 89/646 | 13.8% |
Manuscript Figure 5. Biological responses are required by eligibility. Domain categories overlap; the mutually exclusive combinations are shown separately in the figure.
Overview
Circadian-supportive lighting is often framed as a technology problem, yet real-world outcomes also depend on how biological evidence, light-exposure systems, and occupant engagement work together. As first author and project lead, Ramyar developed the Circadian-Supportive Lighting Triad to connect those three domains in one implementation-oriented framework.
Interactive tool · evidence framework
Build a circadian-lighting implementation question.
Toggle the three evidence domains to see what each combination can answer - and what it leaves unresolved.
Selected implementation lens
Can the system deliver a biologically relevant exposure that people can and will use?
All three domains connect biological intent, technical delivery, and lived use. This is the strongest frame for implementation decisions.
This explorer navigates the review framework; it does not calculate effect size or clinical benefit.
Evidence map
The review maps original human research published from 2015 through 2025. The original multi-database search, a supplementary Scopus search and researcher reassessment contributed an initial pool of 857 records. Final eligibility and coding review retained 728 qualified publications, all with complete reports, grouped into 646 study families.
Reports with verified participant overlap were linked into families so companion publications could contribute their distinct findings without being counted as separate families. The 47 multi-publication families contain 129 publications. Domain-representation analyses use all 646 families with resolved coding; publication-level analyses retain their separate denominator of 728.
What the map reveals
Among the 646 families, 604 (93.5%) addressed Light-Exposure Systems and 89 (13.8%) evaluated qualifying Occupant Engagement. All 646 addressed Non-Visual Biological Responses by eligibility. The mutually exclusive combinations were 515 families addressing biological responses and systems without engagement, 89 addressing all three domains, and 42 addressing biological responses alone. These are counts of research components, rather than intervention effect sizes.
Within the interventional subset, engagement appeared in 86 of 361 families (23.8%). The qualifying-engagement families included seven evaluating active self-monitoring and four evaluating recorded-data feedback. Physically measured personal light exposure was assessed in 29 of the 89 engagement-positive families. These different denominators distinguish the overall evidence map, intervention research and the focused engagement analysis.
Occupant-in-the-loop direction
The proposed direction treats the occupant as part of the control and learning loop rather than a passive recipient. Exposure measurement, building response, understandable feedback, and practical occupant action become connected stages that can be evaluated together.
Publication status and contribution
The manuscript is submitted. As first author and project lead, Ramyar developed the conceptual framework and led methodology, evidence curation, analysis, visualization, drafting and project administration. The current evidence map links 728 publications to 646 study families and uses their findings to guide research connecting biological targets, exposure systems and practical occupant engagement.
