{
  "record": "October 2026 source verification",
  "figures": [
    {
      "name": "small-methods",
      "title": "Small-office heat emissions: two 8-day periods",
      "caption": "Archived Heat Emissions Summary for February 20-27 and July 20-27 inclusive (384 simulated hours). Envelope convection plus zone exfiltration. These are heat emissions, not annual site energy or evidence of solver accuracy.",
      "data": {
        "labels": [
          "Analytical: TARP / TARP",
          "Analytical: TARP / DOE-2",
          "Euler: TARP / DOE-2",
          "Euler: TARP / TARP"
        ],
        "values": [
          64.44,
          65.9,
          65.94,
          64.47
        ],
        "unit": "Heat emissions over 384 hours (GJ)"
      },
      "sources": [
        "ideal_system_Analytical_CTF_TarpTarp_ALBUQUERQUETable.html",
        "ideal_system_Analytical_CTF_TarpDOE_ALBUQUERQUETable.html",
        "ideal_system_Euler_CTF_TarpDOE_ALBUQUERQUETable.html",
        "ideal_system_Euler_CTF_TarpDOE_ALBUQUERQUETable.html"
      ],
      "status": "Archived-source reanalysis; not a fresh simulation",
      "source_record": "/downloads/EnergyPlus-Scientific-Audit.pdf"
    },
    {
      "name": "large-convection",
      "title": "Large-office envelope heat emissions",
      "caption": "Inside / outside convection algorithms. Archived annual simulations (8,760 hours), using Albuquerque weather despite the Denver model filenames. The quantity is envelope convection to the environment; it is not building utility consumption.",
      "data": {
        "labels": [
          "TARP / TARP",
          "TARP / DOE-2",
          "Simple / TARP",
          "Simple / DOE-2"
        ],
        "values": [
          8831.72,
          10201.21,
          8823.08,
          10191.8
        ],
        "unit": "Envelope-convection heat emissions (GJ/year)"
      },
      "sources": [
        "TarpTarp_ASHRAE9012016_OfficeLarge_DenverTable.html",
        "TarpDOE_ASHRAE9012016_OfficeLarge_DenverTable.html",
        "SimpleTarp_ASHRAE9012016_OfficeLarge_DenverTable.html",
        "SimpleDOE_ASHRAE9012016_OfficeLarge_DenverTable.html"
      ],
      "status": "Archived-source reanalysis; not a fresh simulation",
      "source_record": "/downloads/EnergyPlus-Scientific-Audit.pdf"
    },
    {
      "name": "runtime",
      "title": "Historical large-office simulation runtime",
      "caption": "Final report Table 13. Historical elapsed time per run; hardware and repeatability statistics were not documented. These seconds are not annual building energy results.",
      "data": {
        "labels": [
          "Analytical",
          "Euler",
          "Third-order backward difference"
        ],
        "values": [
          266.68,
          245.85,
          235.14
        ],
        "unit": "Elapsed simulation time (seconds per run)"
      },
      "sources": [
        "EP_Report.pdf, PDF p.10, Table 13"
      ],
      "status": "Archived-source reanalysis; not a fresh simulation",
      "source_record": "/downloads/EnergyPlus-Scientific-Audit.pdf"
    },
    {
      "name": "insulation-sweep",
      "title": "Recorded insulation thickness sweep",
      "caption": "Original workbook totals are sums of rounded end uses. Conductivity 0.049 W/(m K); 12 cm was retained. Line segments join tested points only. The vertical axis is cropped to show response. This sweep has a different starting case from the envelope sequence. Points represent discrete tested cases; connecting lines are guides only. The energy axis is cropped to show differences.",
      "data": {
        "x": [
          2,
          4,
          6,
          8,
          10,
          12,
          16,
          20,
          30,
          40,
          50
        ],
        "values": [
          438.21,
          402.49,
          382.42,
          369.89,
          361.09000000000003,
          354.51,
          347.58000000000004,
          344.55999999999995,
          341.38,
          339.12,
          337.19
        ],
        "x_unit": "Insulation thickness (cm)",
        "y_unit": "Annual site energy (GJ/year)"
      },
      "sources": [
        "Insulation_Optimization.xlsx"
      ],
      "status": "Archived-source reanalysis; not a fresh simulation",
      "source_record": "/downloads/EnergyPlus-Scientific-Audit.pdf"
    },
    {
      "name": "sequence-total",
      "title": "Archived envelope/load cases",
      "caption": "Annual Building Utility Performance Summary Total Site Energy. The selected glazing case is the dedicated low-E/15 mm argon/low-E model. The next stage also changes the gap to 10 mm and attic infiltration, so its decrement is a combined model change. These values use the raw total row; the report sums rounded end uses.",
      "data": {
        "labels": [
          "Reference",
          "Insulation",
          "Selected glazing",
          "Infiltration + glazing gap",
          "Lighting",
          "Shading"
        ],
        "values": [
          363.95,
          354.51,
          353.72,
          340.02,
          290.16,
          288.13
        ],
        "unit": "Annual site energy (GJ/year)"
      },
      "sources": [
        "1.BaselineTable.html",
        "2.InsulationTable.html",
        "14.Double_lowE_Argon15_lowETable.html",
        "4.InfiltrationTable.html",
        "5.LightsTable.html",
        "6.ShadingTable.html"
      ],
      "status": "Archived-source reanalysis; not a fresh simulation",
      "source_record": "/downloads/EnergyPlus-Scientific-Audit.pdf"
    },
    {
      "name": "sequence-enduses",
      "title": "Envelope/load cases by end use",
      "caption": "All energy end uses are retained. Labels use the EnergyPlus Total Site Energy row; stacked rounded components may differ by 0.01 GJ. The infiltration-labeled transition includes glazing-gap and attic changes, so component attribution is conditional on that combined change.",
      "data": {
        "labels": [
          "Reference",
          "Insulation",
          "Selected glazing",
          "Infiltration + glazing gap",
          "Lighting",
          "Shading"
        ],
        "totals": [
          363.95,
          354.51,
          353.72,
          340.02,
          290.16,
          288.13
        ],
        "components": {
          "Heating": [
            37.97,
            30.74,
            22.31,
            7.88,
            12.44,
            14.34
          ],
          "Cooling": [
            31.28,
            30.23,
            34.16,
            36.27,
            29.39,
            26.52
          ],
          "Interior Lighting": [
            102.64,
            102.64,
            102.64,
            102.64,
            63.23,
            63.23
          ],
          "Exterior Lighting": [
            43.46,
            43.46,
            43.46,
            43.46,
            43.46,
            43.46
          ],
          "Interior Equipment": [
            87.73,
            87.73,
            87.73,
            87.73,
            87.73,
            87.73
          ],
          "Fans": [
            49.38,
            48.22,
            51.94,
            50.56,
            42.42,
            41.37
          ],
          "Water Systems": [
            11.49,
            11.49,
            11.49,
            11.49,
            11.49,
            11.49
          ]
        }
      },
      "sources": [
        "1.BaselineTable.html",
        "2.InsulationTable.html",
        "14.Double_lowE_Argon15_lowETable.html",
        "4.InfiltrationTable.html",
        "5.LightsTable.html",
        "6.ShadingTable.html"
      ],
      "status": "Archived-source reanalysis; not a fresh simulation",
      "source_record": "/downloads/EnergyPlus-Scientific-Audit.pdf"
    },
    {
      "name": "infiltration",
      "title": "Infiltration and glazing-gap changes",
      "caption": "Selected 15 mm argon glazing case versus the infiltration-stage model, which also uses a 10 mm gap. Conditioned zones use scheduled 0.10 ACH; attic changes from 1.0 to 0.5 ACH. Baseline perimeter infiltration is area-based, not uniform 0.35 ACH.",
      "data": {
        "labels": [
          "Heating",
          "Cooling",
          "Fans",
          "Total site"
        ],
        "before": [
          22.31,
          34.16,
          51.94,
          353.72
        ],
        "after": [
          7.88,
          36.27,
          50.56,
          340.02
        ]
      },
      "sources": [
        "14.Double_lowE_Argon15_lowETable.html",
        "4.InfiltrationTable.html"
      ],
      "status": "Archived-source reanalysis; not a fresh simulation",
      "source_record": "/downloads/EnergyPlus-Scientific-Audit.pdf"
    },
    {
      "name": "lighting",
      "title": "Lighting power density: 19.48 to 12 W/m²",
      "caption": "Archived matched lighting-stage comparison. Heating increases while cooling, fans and lighting fall. The common zero-based energy scale preserves the direction and magnitude of each change.",
      "data": {
        "labels": [
          "Interior Lighting",
          "Heating",
          "Cooling",
          "Fans",
          "Total site"
        ],
        "before": [
          102.64,
          7.88,
          36.27,
          50.56,
          340.02
        ],
        "after": [
          63.23,
          12.44,
          29.39,
          42.42,
          290.16
        ]
      },
      "sources": [
        "4.InfiltrationTable.html",
        "5.LightsTable.html"
      ],
      "status": "Archived-source reanalysis; not a fresh simulation",
      "source_record": "/downloads/EnergyPlus-Scientific-Audit.pdf"
    },
    {
      "name": "orientation",
      "title": "Separate orientation comparison",
      "caption": "This orientation set uses low-E/10 mm argon/clear glazing. The cumulative final model uses low-E on both panes, explaining a distinct comparison basis. It is not an extra stage in the envelope sequence.",
      "data": {
        "labels": [
          "East",
          "North",
          "West",
          "South"
        ],
        "values": [
          294.87,
          288.83,
          296.14,
          289.0
        ],
        "unit": "Annual site energy (GJ/year)"
      },
      "sources": [
        "EastTable.html",
        "NorthTable.html",
        "WestTable.html",
        "SouthTable.html"
      ],
      "status": "Archived-source reanalysis; not a fresh simulation",
      "source_record": "/downloads/EnergyPlus-Scientific-Audit.pdf"
    },
    {
      "name": "glazing-sweep",
      "title": "Archived glazing comparison",
      "caption": "Exact archived annual site totals. Names retain original case IDs; low-E = low-emissivity glazing. The selected glazing case is 14. The shading sweep uses a different inner pane from the cumulative final case.",
      "data": {
        "labels": [
          "1.single clear",
          "2.single lowE",
          "4.Double clear air15 clear",
          "6.Double clear Argon15 clear",
          "8.Double lowE Air15 clear",
          "10.Double lowE Argon15 clear",
          "12.Double lowE Air15 lowE",
          "14.Double lowE Argon15 lowE",
          "15.Triple lowE Argon15 lowE Air15 clear",
          "16.Triple lowE Argon15 lowE Argon15 clear",
          "17.Triple lowE Argon15 lowE Argon15 lowE",
          "18.Triple clear air15 clear air15 clear",
          "19.Triple lowE air15 clear air15 clear",
          "20.Triple lowE argon15 clear air15 clear"
        ],
        "values": [
          374.0,
          368.3,
          361.63,
          361.29,
          356.06,
          355.62,
          354.18,
          353.72,
          348.08,
          347.76,
          347.11,
          355.25,
          350.29,
          350.13
        ],
        "unit": "Annual site energy (GJ/year)"
      },
      "sources": [
        "1.single_clearTable.html",
        "2.single_lowETable.html",
        "4.Double_clear_air15_clearTable.html",
        "6.Double_clear_Argon15_clearTable.html",
        "8.Double_lowE_Air15_clearTable.html",
        "10.Double_lowE_Argon15_clearTable.html",
        "12.Double_lowE_Air15_lowETable.html",
        "14.Double_lowE_Argon15_lowETable.html",
        "15.Triple_lowE_Argon15_lowE_Air15_clearTable.html",
        "16.Triple_lowE_Argon15_lowE_Argon15_clearTable.html",
        "17.Triple_lowE_Argon15_lowE_Argon15_lowETable.html",
        "18.Triple_clear_air15_clear_air15_clearTable.html",
        "19.Triple_lowE_air15_clear_air15_clearTable.html",
        "20.Triple_lowE_argon15_clear_air15_clearTable.html"
      ],
      "status": "Archived-source reanalysis; not a fresh simulation",
      "source_record": "/downloads/EnergyPlus-Scientific-Audit.pdf"
    },
    {
      "name": "shading-sweep",
      "title": "Separate shading-scheme comparison",
      "caption": "Exact archived annual site totals. Names retain original case IDs; low-E = low-emissivity glazing. The selected glazing case is 14. The shading sweep uses a different inner pane from the cumulative final case.",
      "data": {
        "labels": [
          "1 interior fabric shading",
          "2 interior venetian blinds",
          "3 exterior overhang medium",
          "4 exterior overhang large",
          "5 exterior fins small",
          "6 exterior fins medium",
          "7 exterior fins large",
          "8 exterior trees",
          "9 exterior overhang large interior venetian"
        ],
        "values": [
          289.22,
          293.28,
          290.59,
          289.0,
          292.95,
          292.79,
          292.65,
          288.34,
          289.0
        ],
        "unit": "Annual site energy (GJ/year)"
      },
      "sources": [
        "1_interior_fabric_shadingTable.html",
        "2_interior_venetian_blindsTable.html",
        "3_exterior_overhang_mediumTable.html",
        "4_exterior_overhang_largeTable.html",
        "5_exterior_fins_smallTable.html",
        "6_exterior_fins_mediumTable.html",
        "7_exterior_fins_largeTable.html",
        "8_exterior_treesTable.html",
        "9_exterior_overhang_large_interior_venetianTable.html"
      ],
      "status": "Archived-source reanalysis; not a fresh simulation",
      "source_record": "/downloads/EnergyPlus-Scientific-Audit.pdf"
    },
    {
      "name": "ptac-cop",
      "title": "PTAC: Rated cooling COP (W/W)",
      "caption": "Archived PTAC optimization baseline and cooling-COP sweep. Constant 18°C heating and 24°C cooling thermostat inputs. Original reference envelope and loads; not the optimized-envelope case. Points represent discrete tested cases; connecting lines are guides only. The energy axis is cropped to show differences.",
      "data": {
        "x": [
          3,
          4,
          5,
          6
        ],
        "values": [
          311.53,
          304.12,
          299.68,
          296.72
        ],
        "x_unit": "Rated cooling COP (W/W)",
        "y_unit": "Annual site energy (GJ/year)"
      },
      "sources": [
        "1.BaselineTable.html",
        "2.1.COPTable.html",
        "2.2.COPTable.html",
        "2.3.COPTable.html"
      ],
      "status": "Archived-source reanalysis; not a fresh simulation",
      "source_record": "/downloads/EnergyPlus-Scientific-Audit.pdf"
    },
    {
      "name": "ptac-cooling",
      "title": "PTAC: Cooling design supply temperature (°C)",
      "caption": "Archived site totals. This is the zone design supply-temperature sizing input, not the zone thermostat. Lowering it from 14 to 12°C raises energy from 296.72 to 297.36 GJ and occupied cooling unmet time from 0.50 to 48.50 h. Points represent discrete tested cases; connecting lines are guides only. The energy axis is cropped to show differences.",
      "data": {
        "x": [
          14,
          13.5,
          13,
          12.5,
          12
        ],
        "values": [
          296.72,
          296.89,
          297.06,
          297.21,
          297.36
        ],
        "x_unit": "Cooling design supply temperature (°C)",
        "y_unit": "Annual site energy (GJ/year)"
      },
      "sources": [
        "3.1.Supply_CoolingTable.html",
        "3.2.Supply_CoolingTable.html",
        "3.3.Supply_CoolingTable.html",
        "3.4.Supply_CoolingTable.html",
        "3.5.Supply_CoolingTable.html"
      ],
      "status": "Archived-source reanalysis; not a fresh simulation",
      "source_record": "/downloads/EnergyPlus-Scientific-Audit.pdf"
    },
    {
      "name": "ptac-heating",
      "title": "PTAC: Heating design supply temperature (°C)",
      "caption": "The 50°C case is the preceding retained model (296.72 GJ). The first heating-sweep IDF and expanded model use 55°C (295.95 GJ), correcting the workbook/report axis label of 50°C. The 80°C raw Total Site Energy is 292.51 GJ; 292.52 is a rounded-component sum. Points represent discrete tested cases; connecting lines are guides only. The energy axis is cropped to show differences.",
      "data": {
        "x": [
          50,
          55,
          60,
          70,
          80
        ],
        "values": [
          296.72,
          295.95,
          295.27,
          294.03,
          292.51
        ],
        "x_unit": "Heating design supply temperature (°C)",
        "y_unit": "Annual site energy (GJ/year)"
      },
      "sources": [
        "3.1.Supply_CoolingTable.html",
        "4.1.Supply_HeatingTable.html",
        "4.2.Supply_HeatingTable.html",
        "4.3.Supply_HeatingTable.html",
        "4.4.Supply_HeatingTable.html"
      ],
      "status": "Archived-source reanalysis; not a fresh simulation",
      "source_record": "/downloads/EnergyPlus-Scientific-Audit.pdf"
    },
    {
      "name": "ptac-boiler",
      "title": "PTAC: Boiler nominal efficiency (%)",
      "caption": "Archived comparison after COP 6, cooling design supply 14°C and heating design supply 80°C. Total Site Energy values come directly from EnergyPlus, not sums of rounded components. Points represent discrete tested cases; connecting lines are guides only. The energy axis is cropped to show differences.",
      "data": {
        "x": [
          80,
          83.5,
          87,
          90.5,
          94
        ],
        "values": [
          292.51,
          290.93,
          289.47,
          288.13,
          286.89
        ],
        "x_unit": "Boiler nominal efficiency (%)",
        "y_unit": "Annual site energy (GJ/year)"
      },
      "sources": [
        "5.1.Boiler_EffTable.html",
        "5.2.Boiler_EffTable.html",
        "5.3.Boiler_EffTable.html",
        "5.4.Boiler_EffTable.html",
        "5.5.Boiler_EffTable.html"
      ],
      "status": "Archived-source reanalysis; not a fresh simulation",
      "source_record": "/downloads/EnergyPlus-Scientific-Audit.pdf"
    },
    {
      "name": "vav-cop",
      "title": "VAV: Chiller nominal COP (W/W)",
      "caption": "COP 4 is the baseline (418.67 GJ/year). COP 6 is the retained tested value (393.36 GJ/year). These are modeled equipment inputs; no equipment-selection or cost optimum is established. Points represent discrete tested cases; connecting lines are guides only. The energy axis is cropped to show differences.",
      "data": {
        "x": [
          3,
          4,
          5,
          6
        ],
        "values": [
          443.99,
          418.67,
          403.48,
          393.36
        ],
        "x_unit": "Chiller nominal COP (W/W)",
        "y_unit": "Annual site energy (GJ/year)"
      },
      "sources": [
        "2.0.COPTable.html",
        "2.1.COPTable.html",
        "2.2.COPTable.html",
        "2.3.COPTable.html"
      ],
      "status": "Archived-source reanalysis; not a fresh simulation",
      "source_record": "/downloads/EnergyPlus-Scientific-Audit.pdf"
    },
    {
      "name": "vav-fan",
      "title": "VAV: Supply-fan total efficiency (%)",
      "caption": "Total fan efficiency includes motor and fan. The modeled 90% total with 90% motor efficiency implies ideal 100% fan aerodynamic efficiency; treat this endpoint as an idealized parameter case, not a specified real fan. Points represent discrete tested cases; connecting lines are guides only. The energy axis is cropped to show differences.",
      "data": {
        "x": [
          70,
          75,
          80,
          85,
          90
        ],
        "values": [
          393.36,
          390.78,
          388.52,
          386.53,
          384.76
        ],
        "x_unit": "Supply-fan total efficiency (%)",
        "y_unit": "Annual site energy (GJ/year)"
      },
      "sources": [
        "2.3.COPTable.html",
        "3.2.Fan_EffTable.html",
        "3.3.Fan_EffTable.html",
        "3.4.Fan_EffTable.html",
        "3.5.Fan_EffTable.html"
      ],
      "status": "Archived-source reanalysis; not a fresh simulation",
      "source_record": "/downloads/EnergyPlus-Scientific-Audit.pdf"
    },
    {
      "name": "vav-coil",
      "title": "VAV: Cooling-coil design setpoint (°C)",
      "caption": "System coil design setpoint; zone design cooling supply remains 12.8°C. The 12.8 to 11.4°C change lowers annual energy 384.76 to 383.85 GJ and raises occupied cooling unmet time 67.67 to 70.17 h. Points represent discrete tested cases; connecting lines are guides only. The energy axis is cropped to show differences.",
      "data": {
        "x": [
          13.5,
          12.8,
          12.1,
          11.4
        ],
        "values": [
          385.38,
          384.76,
          384.26,
          383.85
        ],
        "x_unit": "Cooling-coil design setpoint (°C)",
        "y_unit": "Annual site energy (GJ/year)"
      },
      "sources": [
        "4.0.Cooling_SetpointTable.html",
        "3.5.Fan_EffTable.html",
        "4.2.Cooling_SetpointTable.html",
        "4.3.Cooling_SetpointTable.html"
      ],
      "status": "Archived-source reanalysis; not a fresh simulation",
      "source_record": "/downloads/EnergyPlus-Scientific-Audit.pdf"
    },
    {
      "name": "ptac-steps",
      "title": "PTAC archived branch",
      "caption": "Branch-specific annual site totals. The repeated PTAC cooling-supply stage is the same retained input. Read with the energy/service comparison; branch savings cannot be added to envelope savings.",
      "data": {
        "labels": [
          "Baseline",
          "COP 6",
          "Cooling design 14°C",
          "Heating design 80°C",
          "Boiler efficiency 94%"
        ],
        "values": [
          311.53,
          296.72,
          296.72,
          292.51,
          286.89
        ],
        "unit": "Annual site energy (GJ/year)"
      },
      "sources": [
        "1.BaselineTable.html",
        "2.3.COPTable.html",
        "3.1.Supply_CoolingTable.html",
        "4.4.Supply_HeatingTable.html",
        "5.5.Boiler_EffTable.html"
      ],
      "status": "Archived-source reanalysis; not a fresh simulation",
      "source_record": "/downloads/EnergyPlus-Scientific-Audit.pdf"
    },
    {
      "name": "vav-steps",
      "title": "VAV archived branch",
      "caption": "VAV branch annual site totals across chiller COP, fan efficiency, coil setpoint and boiler efficiency. This reference-envelope branch remains separate from the envelope/load sequence.",
      "data": {
        "labels": [
          "Baseline, COP 4",
          "Chiller COP 6",
          "Fan total efficiency 90%",
          "Coil design 11.4°C",
          "Boiler efficiency 94%"
        ],
        "values": [
          418.67,
          393.36,
          384.76,
          383.85,
          375.05
        ],
        "unit": "Annual site energy (GJ/year)"
      },
      "sources": [
        "2.1.COPTable.html",
        "2.3.COPTable.html",
        "3.5.Fan_EffTable.html",
        "4.3.Cooling_SetpointTable.html",
        "5.5.Boiler_EfficiencyTable.html"
      ],
      "status": "Archived-source reanalysis; not a fresh simulation",
      "source_record": "/downloads/EnergyPlus-Scientific-Audit.pdf"
    },
    {
      "name": "energy-service",
      "title": "Energy savings alongside delivered thermal service",
      "caption": "Archived whole-facility outputs. PTAC: -7.9% energy, cooling unmet 0.50 to 0.50 h. VAV: -10.4% energy, cooling unmet 67.67 to 70.17 h (+2.50 h). Occupied heating unmet is 0.00 h for all four. Reporting tolerance is 0.556°C. Facility hours count any occupied zone, not summed zone-hours. No acceptance criterion was stated.",
      "data": [
        {
          "path": "Topic3_HVAC/small office - PTAC/Optimization/1.BaselineTable.html",
          "site_GJ": 311.53,
          "heating_unmet_h": 0.0,
          "cooling_unmet_h": 0.5
        },
        {
          "path": "Topic3_HVAC/small office - PTAC/Optimization/5.5.Boiler_EffTable.html",
          "site_GJ": 286.89,
          "heating_unmet_h": 0.0,
          "cooling_unmet_h": 0.5
        },
        {
          "path": "Topic3_HVAC/small office - VAV/Optimization/2.1.COPTable.html",
          "site_GJ": 418.67,
          "heating_unmet_h": 0.0,
          "cooling_unmet_h": 67.67
        },
        {
          "path": "Topic3_HVAC/small office - VAV/Optimization/5.5.Boiler_EfficiencyTable.html",
          "site_GJ": 375.05,
          "heating_unmet_h": 0.0,
          "cooling_unmet_h": 70.17
        }
      ],
      "sources": [
        "1.BaselineTable.html",
        "5.5.Boiler_EffTable.html",
        "2.1.COPTable.html",
        "5.5.Boiler_EfficiencyTable.html"
      ],
      "status": "Archived-source reanalysis; not a fresh simulation",
      "source_record": "/downloads/EnergyPlus-Scientific-Audit.pdf"
    }
  ]
}
